dog dental chews

This or That: Dental Chews Edition

When it comes to keeping our dogs happy and healthy, choosing the right treats is an important decision. Whether it’s for dental health, general enjoyment, or just because they deserve a little snack, the ingredients and benefits of dog treats should be carefully considered. Two popular options are Purina DentaLife Daily Oral Care Tartar Control Dental Dog Treats and Pipers Bark n Bites Pure Duck Feet Dog Treats. While both are designed for doggy enjoyment, the differences in ingredients, health benefits, and treat composition can significantly affect the well-being of your pet. Let’s break down these two treats and see how they compare.

Purina DentaLife Daily Oral Care Tartar Control Dental Dog Treats

Purina’s DentaLife Daily Oral Care treats are formulated to help clean your dog’s teeth and control tartar build-up. These treats are designed to provide oral health benefits, which is a major concern for many pet owners, as dental issues can lead to bigger health problems. The key ingredients as of publication in Purina DentaLife are as follows:

  • Rice & Wheat Flour: These are basic carbohydrate ingredients used for texture and bulk. While not harmful, they aren't contributing much to your dog’s overall nutritional profile.

  • Glycerin: This is used to retain moisture in the treats, ensuring they remain soft and palatable.

  • Sodium Tripolyphosphate: A key ingredient that helps with tartar control by breaking down plaque and tartar on your dog’s teeth as they chew.

  • Chicken By-Product Meal: A protein source, although lower-quality than whole meat. It may not offer the same nutritional benefits as whole protein sources like duck or beef.

  • Preservatives (Sorbic Acid, Calcium Propionate, BHA, BHT): These additives help prolong shelf life but can be a cause for concern for some pet owners, especially when it comes to artificial preservatives, which some prefer to avoid for their pets' health.

While these dog dental treats do offer some tangible oral health benefits, such as tartar control and teeth cleaning, they may come with some concerns. The presence of preservatives, like BHA and BHT, can be controversial. Some studies have suggested that these chemicals might be linked to potential health risks, though they are generally recognized as safe in small quantities by pet food regulatory bodies. Additionally, the use of by-products as a primary protein source is not ideal for those looking for higher-quality, whole-food ingredients for their dogs.

Piper's Bark 'n Bites Duck Feet Dog Treats

In stark contrast to the Purina DentaLife treats, Pipers Bark n Bites Pure Duck Feet Dog Treats are made from a single ingredient: duck feet. There are no preservatives, additives, or artificial chemicals involved in this dental treat, making it an excellent option for dogs with sensitivities or those on a natural diet. Here’s what makes these dog dental treats stand out:

  • Single-Ingredient: Duck feet are the only ingredient in these treats. This makes them a simple and natural choice for your dog, avoiding unnecessary fillers, preservatives, and additives.

  • No Additives or Preservatives: Unlike the Purina treats, Piper's Duck Feet contain absolutely no artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors. This makes them a more holistic option for health-conscious pet owners.

  • Rich in Natural Nutrients: Duck feet are naturally high in protein, collagen, and glucosamine, which can promote joint health and help keep your dog’s coat shiny. They are also a great source of natural chondroitin, which is important for maintaining healthy joints, especially for active dogs.

  • Dental Benefits: The natural chewing action involved in gnawing on duck feet can help clean your dog’s teeth, helping to scrape away plaque and tartar over time, contributing to better oral hygiene.

Comparison of Key Differences

  1. Ingredients & Additives:

    • Purina DentaLife contains multiple ingredients, including preservatives like BHA and BHT, as well as wheat flour, glycerin, and by-products. These may not be ideal for those who are looking for a natural, chemical-free option.
    • Piper's Duck Feet are 100% pure, with no additives or preservatives, making them a more natural and straightforward treat. For those who prioritize minimal processing and a single ingredient, Piper's Bark 'n Bites is the winner.

  2. Health Benefits:

    • Purina DentaLife targets oral health specifically, aiming to reduce tartar build-up and clean your dog’s teeth. The use of sodium tripolyphosphate is especially beneficial for tartar control.
    • Piper's Duck Feet offer oral benefits through natural chewing. Additionally, they provide extra health benefits like joint support due to their natural collagen and glucosamine content.

  3. Preservatives and Fillers:

    • Purina DentaLife contains preservatives like BHA, BHT, and calcium propionate, which some dog owners might want to avoid due to potential long-term health concerns.
    • Piper's Duck Feet are free of preservatives, additives, and artificial ingredients, making them a cleaner and potentially healthier option for dogs with food sensitivities or those on a limited ingredient diet.

  4. Taste & Texture:

    • Purina DentaLife offers a crunchy, chewable texture designed to clean teeth. However, the taste might not be as enticing for every dog, especially those who prefer natural meat flavors.
    • Piper's Duck Feet are chewy and might be particularly appealing for dogs who enjoy gnawing on natural meat-based treats. The texture of duck feet also encourages prolonged chewing, which can be great for teeth and gums.

Which Dog Dental Chew Should You Choose?

The decision between Purina DentaLife Daily Oral Care Tartar Control treats and Piper's Bark 'n Bites Pure Duck Feet depends largely on what you're looking for in a dog treat.

  • If oral health is your primary concern, and you’re looking for a treat specifically designed to reduce tartar and clean your dog’s teeth, Purina DentaLife might be a better fit. However, it does come with added preservatives and ingredients that might not appeal to those seeking a more natural option.

  • If you prefer a single-ingredient, preservative-free treat that provides additional benefits like joint health and a more natural chewing experience, Piper's Duck Feet are an excellent choice. These are ideal for dogs with food sensitivities, or for owners who prefer to avoid unnecessary chemicals and fillers.

Ultimately, both treats offer distinct advantages, so the choice boils down to what aligns best with your dog’s needs and your preferences as a pet owner.

Back to blog